Nuances of Arbitrage Trading: Distinguishing Between Professional and Amateur Forex Traders and Leveraging It to Your Advantage Wednesday April 9th, 2025 – Posted in: Arbitrage Software, Forex trading

Introduction

In this article, we will understand what distinguishes a trader who uses arbitrage strategies from a professional trader and why it is often advantageous to appear as an amateur in a broker’s eyes. To answer this question, we will explore positive and negative slippage, how A-book differs from B-book, and how brokers distinguish professional traders from beginners and amateurs.

What distinguishes a forex market trader from an experienced trader?

The difference between a simple trader using arbitrage strategies and a professional arbitrage trader lies in the approach, quality of execution, and implementation details.

Here are the main differences:

1. Complexity and quality of software and hardware used:
   • Ordinary Forex trader:
     • Uses standard computers, regular VPS, and mass-market trading platforms.
     • His system is often not fast enough to effectively utilize arbitrage opportunities.
   • Professional Forex trader:
     • Uses specialized high-speed servers with low latency, and collocates servers in broker data centers.
     • Utilizes dedicated communication channels and FIX protocols.
2. Access to liquidity and execution:
   • Ordinary Forex trader:
     • Works through retail brokers, where Forex brokers can easily identify and intercept arbitrage.
     • Experiences problems when attempting to withdraw profits earned through arbitrage.
   • Professional Forex trader:
     • Has direct access to deep liquidity through banks and ECN platforms.
     • Works through liquidity aggregators, avoiding broker restrictions on arbitrage.
3. Software and algorithms:
   • Ordinary Forex trader:
     • Uses publicly available and simple algorithms or commercial advisors, which brokers quickly detect.
     • Cannot adapt to changes in trading conditions.
   • Professional Forex trader:
     • Creates their own or uses commercial high-efficiency arbitrage algorithms in Python, C++, C#.
     • Continuously modifies algorithms, adapting to market changes and methods to counter arbitrage.
4. Risk management and capital management:
   • Ordinary Forex trader:
     • Does not always accurately calculate risks, may use capital too aggressively, leading to money loss during strategy failures or broker intervention.
   • Professional Forex trader:
     • Uses strict and detailed risk management.
     • Thinks through scenarios in advance, diversifies accounts, platforms, and strategies, and avoids losses due to broker blockages or sanctions.
5. Knowledge of the market and legal field:
   • Ordinary Forex  trader:
     • Often does not understand the nuances of regulation and does not know which arbitrage methods are allowed or prohibited.
     • Falls under sanctions from brokers.
   • Professional Forex trader:
     • Is well-versed in the legal field, understands the legal aspects of trading.
     • Uses legal and practical approaches, minimizing legal and regulatory risks.

The comparison highlights how a professional arbitrage trader is distinguished primarily by the level of execution, approach professionalism, and infrastructure quality, which allow for consistently extracting profit from market inefficiencies. However, there is one caveat: often this is just theory, and frequently non-professional traders manage to make substantial money by oscillating between which strategy to use, trading from a cheap VPS, etc.

Let’s understand why this can happen and grasp how it can be used to one’s advantage and interest.

Starting with the basics, what is most frightening for any trader and almost any trading strategy, not to mention latency arbitrage, is execution delays and, as a consequence, slippage and sometimes slippage without significant execution delays due to manipulations by forex brokers the trader chose for HFT trading.

Slippage is a situation in the financial market where a trader’s order is executed at a price different from the one the trader expected to see at the time of sending the request. Slippage can be:

• Positive (profitable) — the transaction is executed at a better price.
• Negative (unprofitable) — the transaction is executed at a worse price. Slippage is most often understood to mean negative slippage specifically.

Reasons for slippage:

1. High volatility:
   • During the release of important economic news, the price can change quickly, and the order is executed at a different price.
2. Low liquidity:
   • With an insufficient number of offers on the market, the order is executed at the nearest available price, usually less favorable.
3. Execution delays:
   • Technical delays on the part of the broker or trader can lead to execution of orders at different prices.
4. Large order size:
   • Large orders can significantly move the market price, leading to slippage.

Examples of slippage:

• Negative slippage:
  • A trader wants to buy EUR/USD at a price of 1.2000. While the order is being sent to the broker’s server and executed, the price changed to 1.2003. As a result, the trader bought more expensively by 3 points.
• Positive slippage:
  • A trader wants to sell GBP/USD at 1.2500, and at the moment of execution, the price became 1.2504. The trader got 4 points more.

Slippage is a normal phenomenon that a trader should take into account in their strategy and risk management. However, too frequent and significant negative slippage can be a sign of a poor-quality broker or intentional manipulation of order execution.

Broker manipulations (Forex broker)

A-book vs B-Book

Now let’s move on to broker manipulations, but first, let’s consider the two models, A-book and B-book. Here are the main differences between A-Book and B-Book in Forex brokerage:

1. A-Book (Agency broker model):
   • Description:
     • The broker acts exclusively as an intermediary.
     • Outputs each trader’s transaction to the real interbank market or liquidity provider (banks, ECN, funds, etc.).
   • Broker’s source of income:
     • Earns income only from commissions and spreads.
     • Earnings do not depend on the trader’s losses.
   • Advantages for the trader:
     • No conflict of interest (the broker is not interested in the client’s loss).
     • Transparency in pricing and transaction execution.
     • The broker does not manipulate prices and transactions.
   • Disadvantages for the trader:
     • Possible requotes, slippage, and spread widening during high volatility or low liquidity.
     • High requirements for a minimum deposit.
2. B-Book (Market maker or dealer model):
   • Description:
     • The broker does not output client transactions to the external market but acts as a counterparty to the transaction itself.
     • Trades against the client, earning on his loss.
   • Broker’s source of income:
     • The main income of the broker is the losses of traders.
     • If the client loses, the broker makes a profit.
   • Advantages for the trader (if the broker is wrong):
     • Less likelihood of requotes and slippage, as transactions are executed within the broker.
     • Often better trading conditions (narrow spreads, fast execution), especially if the broker considers the trader’s strategy potentially unprofitable.
   • Disadvantages for the trader:
     • Strong conflict of interest (the broker is interested in the client’s loss).
     • Risk of manipulations, such as artificial price jumps, spread widening, execution delays, virtual dealer intervention.

In short, about the main thing:

Thus, the choice between A-Book and B-Book depends on your trading style, professionalism level, and risk management approach. How a Forex broker manipulates the market. So now we see that in the B-book model, there is a high likelihood of broker manipulation. Let’s figure out how a broker can manipulate

Here’s how to detect if a Forex broker is manipulating trades or using a virtual dealer

1. Unusual Order Execution Delays:
   • Your orders consistently experience suspiciously long delays, especially during profitable trades.
2. Frequent Requotes or Slippage:
   • If you’re regularly experiencing requotes or excessive slippage, particularly during volatile market conditions, it might indicate broker interference.
3. Differing Prices Compared to Other Brokers:
   • The broker’s price quotes significantly differ from reliable sources or major liquidity providers, suggesting artificial manipulation.
4. Price Spikes or Stop Hunting:
   • Sudden price spikes, seemingly designed to trigger stop-loss orders, can be signs of a virtual dealer intervention.
5. Trades Rejected or Blocked During High Profitability:
   • Profitable strategies or specific profitable trades might be consistently denied execution or closed prematurely by the broker.
6. Consistent Negative Slippage Only:
   • If slippage almost always goes against you rather than occasionally benefiting you, this can indicate virtual dealer manipulation.
7. Delayed Platform Updates:
   • Your trading platform occasionally freezes, delays price updates, or suddenly disconnects during critical trading moments.
8. Excessive Spread Widening:
   • Frequent and unjustified spreads widening, especially around key news events, might indicate deliberate broker manipulation. While these signs strongly suggest broker manipulation, it is difficult to prove virtual dealer usage. It’s recommended to compare broker data, document suspicious occurrences, and choose regulated and reputable brokers.

How can a liquidity provider manipulate the market?

Manipulations at the interbank market level or by liquidity providers occur significantly less often than at the retail broker level, but they are still possible. Here’s how they can happen:

1. Spikes (artificial jumps in quotes):
   • Sometimes large banks or liquidity providers may temporarily and artificially widen spreads or sharply change quotes, triggering stop-losses.
2. Using information about large orders:
   • Seeing large bids, liquidity providers can temporarily manipulate prices, forcing market participants to execute trades at less favorable quotes.
3. Last Look (right of last look):
   • The liquidity provider reserves the right to delay the execution of a transaction by a few milliseconds to check if it is profitable for them.
   • As a result, the transaction may be rejected or executed at a worse price.
4. Slippage:
   • At times of high volatility or low liquidity, banks may deliberately delay execution or execute orders at a less favorable price.
5. Front-running (ahead of large orders):
   • A large participant, having received information about future transactions of other banks or clients, takes a profitable position in advance, affecting the market price before the execution of the main order.
6. Widening of spreads during periods of high volatility:
   • At moments of publishing important news or low liquidity, banks sharply widen spreads, reducing the profitability of trading for clients.

Why are such manipulations less common in the interbank market?

• High competition among large banks limits the scale of manipulations.
• Regulatory requirements and control by financial regulators (e.g., FCA, SEC, CFTC) make manipulations risky and costly for banks.
• Reputational risks: banks value their reputation and avoid systemic manipulations.

How to protect yourself from possible manipulations?

• Work with multiple liquidity providers and use liquidity aggregators, which minimize risks.
• Use platforms with a transparent execution model (e.g., ECN/STP).
• Apply protective orders (stop-loss, limit orders) wisely and carefully to avoid manipulation. Thus, although manipulations at the level of liquidity providers and the interbank market do occur, they are rare and more subtle than at the retail level. However, a knowledgeable trader should be aware of such possibilities and be able to take them into account.

If a broker uses B-book and A-book, what strategies will he consider potential for the trader to lose money and put his account in the B-book? Brokers using A-Book and B-Book models typically try to identify potentially unprofitable strategies for the trader in order to place these accounts in the B-Book (i.e., trade against the client).

Why might being an “unprofessional trader” be beneficial in a B-Book?

1. Improved trading conditions:
   • Expecting client losses, the broker usually reduces spreads, improves execution speed, and allows trading of large volumes without slippage and requotes.
2. Reduced likelihood of manipulations:
   • In B-Book, the broker often allows positions to be “sat out” in the hope that the client will lose the deposit themselves, meaning the broker is less inclined to take drastic actions aimed at knocking out the trader (e.g., artificial price jumps).
3. High liquidity and execution of large transactions:
   • When the broker calculates that the trader will lose, he does not send his transactions to the external market (does not output them to A-Book), meaning the trader’s transactions are executed almost instantly and without slippage.
4. Stable profit on broker errors:
   • If the broker incorrectly assesses the risks, the trader can receive stable profits for a long time before the broker notices its mistake and transfers the account back to A-Book or changes the conditions.

So we see that with certain actions, such as using disguises for your strategies under strategies that the broker may consider as unprofitable or mixing a profitable strategy with its full control of the loss level and arbitrage to control profitability, we can get excellent trading conditions for arbitrage or HFT trading.

What strategies or trading methods in the Forex market does the broker consider potentially unprofitable (suitable for B-Book)?

1. Martingale and averaging losses:
   • The trader consistently increases the size of transactions after losing positions in the hope of recouping. These strategies usually end with a complete drain of the account.
2. Lack of risk management:
   • Systematic use of large lots relative to the size of the deposit without stop-losses.
3. Impulsive trading and emotional transactions:
   • Frequent transactions without a clear strategy or emotional decisions, which usually lead to losses.
4. Trading on news without strict risk management:
   • Frequent sharp market movements lead to significant losses for unprepared traders.
5. Use of trading robots with aggressive algorithms:
   • Advisors that often overtrade or aggressively average, increasing the risks of losing funds.
6. Chaotic trading (without a clear plan):
   • Lack of a logical system or trading plan, transactions made based on randomness or intuitive impulses.
7. Short-term scalping with wide spreads:
   • Aggressive scalping on instruments with high spreads almost guarantees gradual losses.

How does the broker act if he identifies a strategy as potentially unprofitable?

• Transfers the account to B-Book, i.e., trades against the client.
• May even temporarily provide better conditions to encourage the trader to increase volumes and lose the deposit faster.
• Allows the opening of large positions and lets the trader “sit out” losses, knowing that in the long term this leads to losses. Thus, brokers monitor the trading styles of their clients, identifying those who are potentially going to lose, and transfer these accounts to B-Book to maximize the use of traders’ inefficient strategies to their advantage. When it is advantageous for a trader to have his strategy identified as unprofitable and given better trading conditions and placed in the B-book It is advantageous for a trader if a broker mistakenly identifies his strategy as unprofitable and transfers the account to B-Book when the trader actually uses a profitable, stable strategy. This can give the trader unique advantages.

How a trader can “deceive” a broker for HFT Trading

• Imitation of Martingale or risky strategies: Initially show signs of risky trading (e.g., temporarily increasing lots, intentional averaging) to get into B-Book.
• Using hybrid strategies: Initially use a deliberately risky trading strategy, then switch to a conservative and disciplined style that provides long-term profit.
• Trading during low-liquidity times: Make transactions during periods of low volatility, creating the appearance of random, chaotic trading, and then switch to well-thought-out and systematic transactions.

Possible risks of this approach:

• The broker may recognize the strategy and transfer the trader back to A-Book, worsening trading conditions.
• In some cases, the broker may apply sanctions (e.g., refuse to withdraw funds if he suspects “manipulation” of trading conditions).

Final recommendation: A trader should be in B-Book only if he has a real advantage in the market, a stable and proven trading strategy, and the ability to manage risks effectively. Then, the broker’s mistaken decision can provide a period of significantly better trading conditions, ensuring additional profit.

>>>Learn more about professional software for Arbitrage Trading – SharpTrader

FAQ

1. What is arbitrage trading? Arbitrage trading involves buying and selling the same asset in different markets simultaneously to take advantage of differing prices for the same asset.

2. What distinguishes a professional trader from an amateur in arbitrage trading? A professional trader typically utilizes advanced technology, has access to superior liquidity and execution methods, and employs sophisticated risk management strategies. An amateur may lack these resources and often relies on less efficient tools and techniques.

3. Why might it appear advantageous for a trader to seem unprofessional to a broker? Appearing unprofessional might lead brokers to underestimate a trader, potentially offering better trading conditions under the assumption that the trader is likely to lose money, which can be exploited by a savvy trader.

4. What is the difference between A-Book and B-Book brokers? A-Book brokers route trades directly to the interbank market, earning money from commissions and spreads without opposing the client’s position. B-Book brokers act as counter-parties to trades, potentially creating a conflict of interest as they earn money when traders lose.

5. How can a broker manipulate market prices? Brokers can manipulate prices through actions like artificial price spikes, stop hunting, and delayed order execution. This can be particularly evident in less regulated or less reputable B-Book operations.

6. What strategies are considered high risk or potentially unprofitable by brokers? Strategies such as Martingale, high-frequency scalping without adequate risk management, or trading based on emotional decisions are often considered high risk. Brokers might classify these under their B-Book to manage their risk exposure.

7. How can traders protect themselves from broker manipulation? Traders can protect themselves by choosing well-regulated brokers, using protective stop-loss orders, diversifying their brokerage relationships, and continuously monitoring for signs of manipulation like unusual slippage or frequent requotes.

8. Can a trader really benefit from being classified under B-Book? While being under B-Book can offer better initial trading conditions, it carries risks of broker manipulation. Skilled traders might exploit these conditions temporarily, but it requires vigilance and a robust trading strategy to maintain profitability.

9. What legal protections do traders have against broker manipulation? Legal protections vary by jurisdiction but generally include access to a regulatory body for complaints, transparency requirements for brokers, and the possibility of legal recourse in cases of fraud or breach of contract.

10. What should a trader consider when choosing between an A-Book and a B-Book broker? Traders should consider their trading style, risk tolerance, and the level of transparency they desire from their broker. A-Book brokers are typically preferred for their direct market access and lower conflict of interest, whereas B-Book brokers might offer better spreads and bonuses but with increased risk of manipulation.